When Sylvester, the Duke of Salford, first meets Phoebe Marlow, he finds her dull and insipid. She finds him insufferably arrogant. But when a series of unforeseen events leads them to be stranded together in a lonely country inn, they are both forced to reassess their hastily formed opinions, and begin a new-found liking and respect for each other. Sylvester calls to mind the satirical genius of a Jane Austen novel and is adored for its wit and a fast-paced plot that ranges across a myriad of settings. Read Swooning over Sylvester Chloé Harmsworth’s report on Richard Armitage’s new recording of Georgette Heyer’s classic novel. Find out more about Sylvester below.
4 CDs | Running Time: 4h 51m | ISBN: 978-962-634-925-0 | Cat. no.: NA492512 | RRP: £16.99RRP:£16.99 GBPSRP: US $ 28.98RRP:£16.99 GBP
Sylvester – subtitled The Wicked Uncle – is in many ways vintage Georgette Heyer. Published in 1957, when she was at the height of her popularity, it features a flawed yet ultimately deserving hero; a naïve, strong-willed young heroine; meticulous historical accuracy; plenty of wit; and, of course, a happy ending. And as with all Heyer’s novels, it is packed with fascinating insights into the Regency period – she was possessed of a vast knowledge of the era – and there are many references to real people and places.
For instance, one of her ‘characters’, Edward Hughes Ball Hughes (c. 1798–1863) – otherwise known as ‘Golden Ball’ – was an extremely wealthy dandy of the period, famed for his over-elaborate dress and prodigious spending habits. In Heyer’s book, he is mentioned in passing by her hero Sylvester, the Duke of Salford, when he describes Sir Nugent Fotherby as being ‘as rich as Golden Ball’. However, the comparison goes deeper than that – Fotherby is portrayed as a gaudy figure of ridicule, an absurd, tasteless dandy who, like Golden Ball, squanders his money on clothes and cards. It is interesting to note that Heyer chooses a travelling coach as an example of Fotherby’s conspicuous consumption – Ball Hughes was particularly renowned for his bespoke chocolate-coloured coach. Perhaps unsurprisingly, given the abundance of fashionable young men among the wealthy Regency upper classes, the dandy is a frequently lampooned archetype in Heyer’s work. Well-known figures such as Beau Brummel inspired a generation of young men to dress in the foppish way described so accurately by Heyer.
Lady Sefton and Lady Castelreagh, both of whom receive passing mentions in Sylvester, were real-life (and very eminent) members of the aristocracy. Crucially, they were both Patronesses of Almack’s Assembly Rooms, one of the most exclusive social venues of the period. The Patronesses were essentially the arbiters of acceptance into the ton (Regency high society), meeting every Monday to decide who should or should not be allowed entry into Almack’s. Their approval was essential for anyone wishing to become a member of their exclusive circle – their disapproval meant social ostracism and disgrace.
Phoebe’s trepidation at being cut by these fearsome women is not difficult to understand, particularly as, in 1816, less than two years before the events in the novel take place, a strikingly similar scandal occurred that both delighted and horrified ‘society’. Taking her revenge against Lord Byron after their affair ended badly, Lady Caroline Lamb published Glenarvon – a Gothic novel featuring satirical depictions of well-known society figures and, in particular, a bitter, thinly disguised portrait of Byron himself. Although the novel was published anonymously (and became wildly popular), Lamb had her Almack’s voucher rescinded and was exiled from fashionable society. Phoebe would have been aware of the furore – would probably even have read the book – and she would have known of Lady Caroline’s fate.
Literature – in particular the romantic novel – is an important theme in Sylvester. Heyer even uses it to identify the year in which the novel is set. Discussing books with Tom, Sylvester mentions The Knight of St John, which he says ‘came out last year’. This puts the action of the novel in 1818, as The Knight of St John, a romance by the popular contemporary author Anna Maria Porter, was published the year before. The Regency period was a time when Gothic and romantic novels such as Phoebe’s The Lost Heir were extremely popular, and it is entirely possible that authors could find themselves catapulted into sudden notoriety. Phoebe herself makes reference to Byron’s well-known comment about the enthusiastic response to his narrative poem Childe Harold’s Pilgrimage: ‘I awoke one morning and found myself famous.’
There are some interesting parallels between Phoebe and her creator. Heyer started writing her first novel, The Black Moth, at the age of 17, while Phoebe is 18 when she writes The Lost Heir. Both are Gothic adventure stories. Phoebe’s love of books is encouraged by her governess, while Heyer’s father, George Heyer, nurtured a love of literature in his daughter. As a child, Heyer would spend hours discussing books with her friends Carola Oman and Joanna Cannan, both of whom grew up to be authors.
The Black Moth was published, with George Heyer’s help, in 1921. Unlike The Lost Heir, it did not make its author suddenly famous, but it did initiate a steady stream of novels and, in 1926, Heyer had her first major success with These Old Shades. By this time, she had been married for a year to a young mining engineer, Ronald Rougier, and had already published five books.
From 1932 until her death in 1974, Heyer produced novels at the extraordinary rate of almost one a year, spawning a new literary genre – the Regency romance. Yet despite her undeniable success, she was frequently troubled by plagiarism and financial problems. Throughout the 1950s and 1960s, her company Heron Enterprises was a source of contention between her and the tax authorities, and a large chunk of the profits from books written around this time went towards paying back money to the Treasury. Plagiarism also became a problem – from the 1950s onwards, several other writers traded on her popularity by writing novels using names, phrases and events from her books. She was even accused by some of her fans of publishing substandard work under a pseudonym. Although Heyer sought legal advice on several occasions, she never chose to sue.
Sylvester, published in 1957, is a product of these troubled years, and perhaps this goes some way to explaining the pseudo-autobiographical elements of the plot. Despite her immense popularity, Heyer was an intensely private person, answering the curiosity of inquisitive fans by saying ‘you will find me in my work’. She never really seems to have been comfortable with her identity as an author of romantic novels, and she was unsentimental about her work, even referring to it as ‘nonsense’. She did not preserve her manuscripts, and only kept a few reviews. Just one fan letter remained in her keeping – from a Romanian political prisoner who wrote that she had spent twelve years in prison, telling and re-telling the plot of Friday’s Child (1944) to her fellow inmates to keep themselves sane.
Heyer seems to have existed almost as two separate people: Georgette Heyer, the famous author, and Mrs Ronald Rougier – private, reclusive and enigmatic (so much so that her married name was first revealed in her obituary). Her work, with its unique juxtaposition of light-hearted romance and meticulous historical accuracy, echoes this uneasy dualism. Perhaps Sylvester – with its preoccupation with literature and authorship – was a way for her to come to terms with these personal issues and ‘find herself in her work’.
Ultimately, of course, we can never know the ‘real’ Georgette Heyer, but perhaps this doesn’t matter. Her novels sparkle with energy, intelligence and wit – and this is how she is known and remembered by her readers.
Notes by Caroline Waight
See also: Swooning over Sylvester – Chloé Harmsworth’s report on Richard Armitage’s new recording of Georgette Heyer’s classic novel.
This Regency romance first published in 1957 by the prolific novelist Heyer, who is considered by many to be the creator of the genre, is very reminiscent of Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice, and the accomplished, charming, British heart-throb Richard Armitage couldn’t be a better choice for reader. When arrogant aristocrat Sylvester, the Duke of Salford first meets plain. smart and witty Phoebe Marlow sparks fly and they dislike each other enormously, especially when Phoebe’s novel, that contains an unflattering, exaggerated caricature based on Salford – and easily recognizable as him – as one of the characters, ispublished. Over the course of the story as Phoebe and Salford frequently see more of each other. of course, the attraction increases. Heyer, celebrated for the accuracy of period details in her novels, evokes much in this novel of her own experiences dealing with writing, publishing and the reading public as heroine Phoebe is publishing her first novel. Although this is an abridged version of Heyer’s work, British actor Richard Armitage makes this exceptionally fun to listen to. The only drawback is that listeners will be disappointed that he didn’t read the full-length version. Armitage is perhaps best known for playing the most appealing John Thornton in the BBC production of Elizabeth Gaskell’s North and South. He also played the dastardly Guy of Gisborne in Robin Hood, and, a spy in Spooks. Armitage’s reading is warm, lively, simply brilliant. He easily voices all characters and regional and class differences with ease and captures the underlying tension and growing romantic interest between Phoebe and Sylvester. The period classical music between chapters adds wonderful, appropriate atmosphere.
Jean Palmer, Soundcommentary.com
Georgette Heyer’s Sylvester read by Richard Armitage. British heart-throb Richard Armitage couldn’t be a better choice for reader... [and he]... makes this exceptionally fun to listen to.
Jean Palmer, SoundCommentary.com
...Talking of Regency romance, a favourite Georgette Heyer novel is Sylvester, which has a wicked uncle, a feisty heroine, a clash of personalities, a desperately cute child and a daffy mama. It’s also read by the seductive-voiced Richard Armitage, just the pick me up for the end of winter.
Kati Nicholl, Daily Express
I have nothing but good to say about Naxos’ production of Sylvester. It is narrated by Richard Armitage. And he does such a wonderful job with it! He brings the characters – both male and female – to life. It was easy for me to follow the story – to know who was speaking at any given time. (That’s not always easy to do with just one narrator.) There is just enough drama to keep it lively. It is abridged. But there is still so much to love! I would definitely recommend this one!
Becky Laney, Becky’s Book Reviews